Aphasia vs Dysarthria: Key Differences & Symptoms
- Sounderic
- Mar 1, 2023
- 7 min read
Updated: Jul 22, 2025
The primary difference between Aphasia and Dysarthria is that Aphasia is a language disorder, affecting an individual's ability to understand or express language, while Dysarthria is a motor speech disorder affecting an individual's ability to physically produce speech due to weak or uncoordinated muscles.
Being the center for firing all the impulses required for proper functioning of our body, the physiology of our brain is quite complex. Hence when it comes to treatment of brain injuries, it can be quite complicated. If there is damage to the language center, it can result in various conditions, Aphasia and Dysarthria are two major conditions that affect the ability of a person to communicate.
What is Aphasia?
Aphasia is a generalized term often used when a person suffers with partial or complete loss of the ability to speak, understand, read or write language, thereby affecting the ability of a person to communicate effectively. This can be either due to some disease or injury to the brain areas responsible for language processing, commonly after a stroke or traumatic brain injury (TBI).
Causes of Aphasia
Any condition that can damage the brain structure or disrupt the brain function can lead to Aphasia. The common known causes of Aphasia are:
Stroke also known as transient ischemic attack, leads to lack of blood supply to the brain leading to death of the brain cells, ultimately disrupting the brain function.
Alzheimer’s disease
Aneurysm is abnormal dilatation and weakening of blood vessels.
Concussion or Traumatic brain injury
Epilepsy or seizures.
Genetic causes like Wilson's disease
Toxins, like carbon monoxide inhalation.
Symptoms based on types of Aphasia.
Aphasia can present with a wide range of symptoms based on the location of injury in the brain. Most often medical practitioners divide the types of Aphasia based on the ability of the patient to repeat the words, speak fluently, and understand what others say to them.
Few types of Aphasia are:
Wernicke's Aphasia: It is also known as fluent Aphasia. The person can speak fluently in sentences that often don't make any sense. They have difficulty understanding what other people are saying. The patient is often unaware that they aren't able to communicate effectively.
Broca's Aphasia: Also known as expressive Aphasia. The person understands what is being said to them, but they end up facing difficulties in choosing the correct words to express themselves, often leading to frustration and irritation.
Global Aphasia: It is observed in cases of extensive brain injury. The person has difficulty both in understanding others and expressing themselves. It is often accompanied with defects like loss of vision, or paralysis.
Diagnosis of Aphasia
Diagnosing Aphasia requires physical checkup, detailed history taking, diagnostic imaging (CT,MRI) and communication assessments by a speech-language pathologist (SLP).
Treatment of Aphasia
Treatment and recovery from Aphasia are majorly based on the extent of brain damage. A trusted speech therapist can help you overcome the condition.
If a person suffers less damage they can completely recover with minimal loss of normal functioning. But if a person suffers extensive damage, the recovery might not be complete and the goal is to regain the lost skills and learn new ones through pictures, gestures, and technology.
Treatment focuses on speech therapy tailored to the individual's needs, promoting recovery through exercises, alternative communication methods, and family education.
What is Dysarthria?
Dysarthria is a motor speech disorder caused by weakness or poor coordination of the muscles involved in speech production. It occurs due to damage to regions of the brain involved in the motor control over the tongue, throat, muscles of speech, and impaired regulation of airflow.
Common causes of Dysarthria include:
Stroke, severe trauma to the brain, and brain tumors.
Parkinson’s disease
Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS)
Multiple sclerosis, and motor neuron degenerative disease.
Genetic conditions like Down’s syndrome and Huntington's disease.
Myasthenia Gravis
Symptoms of Dysarthria
A person suffering from Dysarthria mainly presents with difficulty in speaking, as the muscles involved in speech are either weak or it is difficult for the person to control them. It can present as:
Mumbled, broken, or robotic speech
Weak or breathy voice
Difficulty controlling lip, tongue, and facial movements
Rate of speech is either too fast or too slow
Slurred speech
Nasal and raspy voice
The person often ends up having an impact on their social and personal relationships. In a few people this can lead to depression and social isolation.
Types of Dysarthria
Dysarthria is often classified into subtypes based on the location of injury in the brain and the abnormal speech pattern.
Flaccid dysarthria is when the lower motor neurons (connect the brain to muscles) are affected.
Spastic dysarthria occurs when upper motor neurons (connects higher centers in the brain) are affected.
Ataxic dysarthria occurs when the connection of various centers of the brain with the cerebellum is affected.
Hyperkinetic and hypokinetic dysarthria occurs when damage to control centers of muscles of head, neck, and limbs.
Diagnosis of Dysarthria
If you have dysarthria, you will be referred for neurological exams and speech-language evaluations. They will evaluate your condition and assess the type of dysarthria.
Treatment of Dysarthria
Speech therapy often includes:
Exercise to strengthen tongue and facial muscles.
Regulating your breathing.
Regulating your speech when talking, for example, slowing down and focusing on speaking clearly.
Using various communication aids like picture boards, gestures, electronic devices, various apps, etc.
Difference between Aphasia and Dysarthria
Here’s a quick comparison table summarizing the key differences between aphasia and dysarthria:
Aspect | Aphasia | Dysarthria |
Underlying cause | Damage to brain areas responsible for language processing (e.g., Broca’s or Wernicke’s areas) | Damage to brain areas controlling the muscles needed for speech (motor speech disorder) |
Affected Abilities | Language abilities: speaking, understanding, reading, writing | Motor control of speech: strength, coordination of lips, tongue, throat |
Comprehension | May be impaired depending on type (especially in Wernicke’s aphasia) | Typically normal — understands language but has difficulty producing clear speech |
Speech clarity | Speech may include incorrect or jumbled words; fluency depends on type of Aphasia | Speech is slurred, mumbled, or slow due to poor muscle control |
Typical causes/events | Stroke, traumatic brain injury, neurological disease affecting language centers | Stroke, Parkinson’s disease, ALS, head injury affecting motor control of speech |
Recovery outlook | Varies based on location and severity of brain damage | Varies; focus on clarity and compensation |
As both aphasia and dysarthria occur due to damage to brain centers, sometimes a person can present with both conditions simultaneously. It is known as a mixed receptive-expressive language disorder.
Can Aphasia and Dysarthria Occur Together?
Yes, Aphasia and Dysarthria can occur together, especially in cases where a stroke or traumatic brain injury (TBI) causes widespread damage affecting both language centers and motor control areas of the brain. Careful assessment by an SLP helps differentiate and address both conditions.
Examples from Stroke and TBI Cases:
After a severe stroke, some individuals may experience Broca’s aphasia (difficulty finding and expressing words) along with spastic dysarthria (strained, slurred speech).
In TBI cases, diffuse brain injury can lead to impairments in both language processing and speech muscle control, resulting in mixed symptoms.
Overlapping Symptoms:
While these are two distinct disorders — Aphasia is a language disorder and Dysarthria is a motor speech disorder. People with both conditions may show:
Slow, effortful speech
Reduced intelligibility
Difficulty expressing thoughts clearly even when comprehension is intact
Importance of Accurate Diagnosis:
An accurate evaluation is essential to differentiate between the two conditions and recognize when they overlap. A speech-language pathologist will carefully assess:
Comprehension abilities
Language formulation skills
Motor speech control and clarity
This ensures that therapy can target the individual’s specific needs — whether that means working on language recovery, speech clarity, or both.
Living with Aphasia or Dysarthria
Aphasia and Dysarthria can affect many aspects of daily life — from casual conversations to workplace interactions. But with the right strategies and support, people can improve communication and maintain meaningful connections.
Tips for Patients and Caregivers:
Be patient: Give extra time for communication without rushing or interrupting.
Encourage alternative communication: Use gestures, pictures, or writing when needed.
Simplify conversations: Speak in short, clear sentences and reduce background noise.
Celebrate small wins: Acknowledge progress, no matter how small.
Communication Strategies at Home and Work:
Establish predictable routines: This reduces communication demands in daily activities.
Use tools: Communication boards, apps, and speech-generating devices can support expression.
Inform colleagues/friends: Let them know about the condition so they can adjust their communication style respectfully.
Break information into smaller chunks: This can make it easier for the person to process and respond.
Local Resources, Support Groups, and Community Connections:
Join support groups: Many cities have aphasia or stroke support groups where individuals and families can share experiences.
Explore online communities: Virtual support networks can offer connection and advice when local options are limited.
Seek professional guidance: A speech-language therapist can help tailor communication strategies and suggest local resources.
FAQs: Aphasia and Dysarthria
What is the main difference between Aphasia and Dysarthria?
Aphasia is a language disorder affecting the ability to understand, speak, read, or write, while Dysarthria is a motor speech disorder affecting muscle control needed for clear speech.
What are the symptoms of Aphasia vs Dysarthria?
Aphasia symptoms include difficulty finding words, forming sentences, or understanding language. Dysarthria symptoms include slurred, slow, or mumbled speech due to weak or uncoordinated speech muscles.
Can someone have both Aphasia and Dysarthria?
Yes, after conditions like stroke or traumatic brain injury, both can occur together if areas responsible for language and speech motor control are affected.
How are these disorders diagnosed?
A speech-language pathologist (SLP) assesses communication abilities, along with medical imaging tests (like MRI or CT scans) to identify the areas of brain damage.
What causes Aphasia or Dysarthria after a stroke?
A stroke can interrupt blood flow to areas of the brain responsible for language (aphasia) or motor control of speech muscles (dysarthria), resulting in damage and impaired communication.
Is there a cure for Aphasia or Dysarthria?
There is no single “cure,” but speech therapy can help people recover skills, improve communication, and develop compensatory strategies for daily life.
What therapy options are available in India?
Speech-language therapy is widely available both in-person and online in India, with many experienced SLPs specializing in neurogenic communication disorders.
How long does recovery typically take?
Recovery depends on the severity and location of brain damage. Some people improve significantly in weeks or months, while others require long-term support.
What can family members do to help?
Family members can create a patient, supportive environment, use simple language, listen attentively, and help with therapy practice at home.
Are there any support groups for these conditions?
Yes, there are local and online support groups for stroke survivors and individuals living with aphasia or dysarthria, offering community and resources for both patients and caregivers.
Sounderic provides online speech therapy sessions for children and adults with various communication disorders globally. We would love to help you. Get in touch with us on WhatsApp at +919644466635 or schedule a consultation with us.
Follow us on Facebook, and Instagram or join our community of 18,000 parents from all across the world here, "Speech therapy guide for parents".
References:
